| Aaron, Hank | |
| Alomar, Roberto | |
| Alston, Walter | |
| Anderson, Sparky | |
| Aparicio, Luis | |
| Appling, Luke | |
| Averill, Earl | |
| Ashburn, Richie | |
| Bancroft, Dave | |
| Keeler, Willie | |
| Banks, Ernie | |
| Barrow, Ed | |
| Barlick, Al | |
| Bell, Cool Papa | |
| Bench, Johnny | |
| Berra, Yogi | |
| Blyleven, Bert | |
| Boggs, Wade | |
| Bottomley, Jim | |
| Boudreau, Lou | |
| Brett, George | |
| Brock, Lou | |
| Bunning, Jim | |
| Campanella, Roy | |
| Carew, Rod | |
| Carey, Max | |
| Carlton, Steve | |
| Carter, Gary | |
| Cepeda, Orlando | |
| Chance, Frank | |
| Chandler, Happy | |
| Clemente, Roberto | |
| Cobb, Ty | |
| Cochrane, Mickey | |
| Collins, Eddie | |
| Collins, Jimmy * | |
| Coveleski, Stan | |
| Cox, Bobby | |
| Crawford, Sam | |
| Cronin, Joe | |
| Cuyler, Kiki | |
| Dandridge, Ray | |
| Dawson, Andre | |
| Dean, Dizzy | |
| Dickey, Bill | |
| DiMaggio, Joe | |
| Doby, Larry | |
| Doerr, Bobby | |
| Drysdale, Don | |
| Durocher, Leo | |
| Eckersley, Dennis | |
| Evers, Johnny | |
| Feller, Bob (player collection) | |
| Ferrell, Rick | |
| Fingers, Rollie | |
| Fisk, Carlton | |
| Ford, Whitey | |
| Fox, Nellie | |
| Foxx, Jimmie | |
| Frick, Ford | |
| Frisch, Frankie | |
| Gehrig, Lou | |
| Gehringer, Charlie | |
| Gibson, Bob | |
| Giles, Warren | |
| Gillick, Pat | |
| Glavine, Tom | |
| Gomez, Lefty | |
| Goslin, Goose | |
| Gossage, Goose | |
| Greenberg, Hank | |
| Grimes, Burleigh | |
| Grove, Lefty | |
| Gwynn, Tony | |
| Harris, Bucky | |
| Hartnett, Gabby | |
| Harvey, Doug | |
| Heilmann, Harry | |
| Henderson, Rickey | |
| Herman, Billy | |
| Herzog, Whitey | |
| Hornsby, Rogers | |
| Hoyt, Waite | |
| Hubbell, Carl | |
| Huggins, Miller | |
| Hunter, Catfish | |
| Irvin, Monte | |
| Jackson, Reggie | |
| Jackson, Travis | |
| Jenkins, Ferguson | |
| Johnson, Judy | |
| Kaline, Al | |
| Keeler, Willie | |
| Kell, George (player collection) | |
| Kelly, George | |
| Killebrew, Harmon | |
| Kiner, Ralph (player collection) | |
| Klein, Chuck | |
| Koufax, Sandy | |
| Lajoie, Napoleon | |
| Larkin, Barry | |
| La Russa, Tony | |
| LaSorda, Tommy | |
| Lazzeri, Tony | |
| Lemon, Bob | |
| Leonard, Buck | |
| Lindstrom, Fred | |
| Lopez, Al | |
| Lyons, Ted | |
| MacPhail, Lee | |
| Maddux, Greg | |
| Mantle, Mickey | |
| Manush, Heinie | |
| Marichal, Juan | |
| Marquard, Rube | |
| Mathews, Eddie | |
| Mathewson, Christy | |
| Mays, Willie | |
| Mazeroski, Bill | |
| McCarthy, Joe | |
| McCovey, Willie | |
| McGraw, John | |
| Medwick, Joe | |
| Mize, Johnny | |
| Molitor, Paul | |
| Morgan, Joe | |
| Murray, Eddie | |
| Musial, Stan | |
| Newhouser, Hal | |
| Niekro, Phil | |
| Ott, Mel | |
| Paige, Satchel | |
| Palmer, Jim | |
| Perez, Tony | |
| Perry, Gaylord | |
| Puckett, Kirby | |
| Reese, Pee Wee | |
| Rice, Jim | |
| Rice, Sam | |
| Ripken, Cal | |
| Rizzuto, Phil | |
| Roberts, Robin | |
| Robinson, Brooks | |
| Robinson, Frank | |
| Robinson, Jackie | |
| Roush, Edd | |
| Ruffing, Red | |
| Ruth, Babe | |
| Ryan, Nolan | |
| Sandberg, Ryne | |
| Santo, Ron | |
| Schmidt, Mike | |
| Schoendienst, Red | |
| Seaver, Tom | |
| Sewell, Joe | |
| Simmons, Al | |
| Sisler, George | |
| Slaughter, Enos | |
| Smith, Ozzie | |
| Snider, Duke | |
| Spahn, Warren | |
| Speaker, Tris | |
| Stargell, Willie | |
| Stengel, Casey | |
| Sutter, Bruce | |
| Sutton, Don | |
| Terry, Bill | |
| Thomas, Frank - original | |
| Thomas, Frank | |
| Tinker, Joe | |
| Torre, Joe | |
| Vaughan, Arky | |
| Wagner, Honus | |
| Waner, Lloyd | |
| Waner, Paul | |
| Waner, Paul and Lloyd | |
| Weaver, Earl | |
| Wheat, Zach | |
| Wilhelm, Hoyt | |
| Williams, Billy | |
| Williams, Dick | |
| Williams, Ted | |
| Wilson, Hack | |
| Winfield, Dave | |
| Wynn, Early | |
| Yastrzemski, Carl | |
| Yount, Robin | click here for list of HOFers for whom I still need game-used cards |